Sunday, December 10, 2006

I believe...

That the term 'ignorance is bliss' is way off mark. I happened across this link at Writer's Market -- take a gander.

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/07/books/07pync.html?_r=1&ref=arts&oref=slogin

I find it truly astounding that the article against McEwan ever found its way to print. Plagiarism is indeed vile and should be stomped ruthlessly when found. However, there is a vast difference between plagiarism and the results of research and proper writing of procedures.

Writers research everything from police procedures to hospital procedures and so on. If the topic is touched on in the novel chances are the writer has spent time researching it. That said, there are realistically only so many ways things are done in this world. Must writers have to incessently find 'new' ways to describe them? If so then not only would our fiction read like tripe but it'd confuse the hell out of readers -- particularly those who do know how things work in a given field.

In this instance, Mr. McEwan is accused of plagiarism because he describes the techniques that a period hospital uses. Without creating such absurdities such as 'He jumped twice, turned in circle, doused the bandage in fuel from an alien ship and then smacked it on his patient' there truly are only so many ways you can apply a bandage.

I find this modern plague of finger pointing and court trials over such flimsy cases of plagiarism disturbing.

Face it folks, nothing 'original' or 'authentic' has been written since the bible and if we include verbal storytelling…nothing new since we learned how to speak. Since days untold writers have been building off of the research and imagination of other writers. Nothing is created from a vacuum and that certainly includes fiction.

____________________

About the Author -

Raven Bower is the author of the upcoming horror novel, Apparitions (ArcheBooks April 2007)

Apparitions Blog

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

1 Comments:

Blogger Markus Niemi said...

... that some of the time the lawsuits of plagarism have nothing to do with with the and more with greed.

Let's face it, whenever an author manages to make a success of his or her novel, there will a dozen people lined up at the door wanting 'their cut', because they 'gave valuable contributions'.

Plagarism - stealing someone else's hard work is awful and should not be tolerated at all; but neither should be trying to steal someone else's success and ruining their reputation.

Mon Dec 11, 11:42:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home